Book Review: ‘After Her’ by Joyce Maynard

From Goodreads:

It’s the summer of 1979, and a dry, hot, northern California school vacation stretches ahead for Rachel and her younger sister Patty-the daughters a larger-than-life, irresistibly handsome and chronically unfaithful detective father who loves to make women happy, and the mother whose heart he broke.

Left to their own devices, the inseparable sisters spend their days studying record jackets, concocting elaborate fantasies about the life of the mysterious neighbor who moves in down the street, and playing dangerous games on the mountain that rises up behind their house.

When young women start showing up dead on the mountain, the girls’ father is charged with finding the man responsible, known as The Sunset Strangler. Seeing her father’s life slowly unravel when he fails to stop the murders, Rachel embarks on her most dangerous game yet: setting herself up as bait to catch the killer, with consequences that will destroy her father’s career and alter the lives of everyone she loves.

It is not until thirty years later that Rachel, who has never given up hope of vindicating her father, finally smokes out the killer, bringing her back to the territory of her childhood, and uncovering a long-buried family secret.

As with her novel, Labor Day, Maynard’s newest work is part thriller, part love story, Loosely inspired by the Trailside Killer case that terrorized Marin County in the late seventies, her tale delves deep into the alternately thrilling and terrifying landscape of a young girl’s first explorations of adult sexuality and the loss of innocence, the bond between sisters-and into a daughter’s tender but damaged relationship with her father, and what it is to finally trust a man.

My review:

I gave this book 3/5

You know when you read a book, and although you don’t hate it (not by a long shot) it just doesn’t ever really get to where you feel it should have been able to get to.

The best part of the entire book exists in the nuanced and caring  relationship between the sisters Rachel & Patty.  It also breathes in the relationship between the two girls and their hard at work,  womanizing (but well meaning) but emotionally wrought father.

While the parts of the book dedicated to the girls growing up are substantial, the ending and what is supposed to be the “payoff” seems rushed and doesn’t quite deliver in the way the synopsis promised.  Not that I would want or need this book to be longer, just better balanced.